Listen With Others

Are you sitting comfortably? Then we'll begin.

Archive for the ‘Solving Blogs’ Category

Listener 4187: Dysart’s Prize & Prize-winner

Posted by Dave Hennings on 18 May 2012

Oh dear, it’s Dysart again! This is the setter who caused me so much wailing and gnashing of teeth last July when his Father Brown puzzle brought my run of 120+ correct Listeners to a screeching halt. Since then, I have had a handful of other failures or silly mistakes, including the unforgivable omission of the highlighting of some stupid carrots!

Anyway, to the task in hand … to somehow beat Dysart this week.

Listener 4187For the first time in what seems an age, the clues were all normal, all entries were to be entered without adulteration, and there were no clashes. In the finished grid, an author and his place of birth would be obvious, together with four of his works. An easy week lay ahead!

I won’t do my usual trick of giving the first clues I solved followed by a statement to the effect that “everything was pretty straightforward after that”. This is mainly because most of the clues were tricky and some held me up for quite a long while.

Instead I’ll just mention the last few clues I got — ones that gave obvious answers, but where the wordplay eluded me for quite a while.

34ac held be up for some time early on because I stupidly just put in IAMBI instead of IAMBS! This made 28dn M-I-S-E-S totally impossible!

15ac Amphibian, name unknown, caught by a thrust was ANURAN … NU (name unknown) in A + RAN (where ‘thrust’ is to be read not as a noun or even the present tense, but the past tense).

45ac Memo: “A person with no regular income is out of the question!” gave NOTE (NOT E); this clue introduced me to E meaning a person with no regular income which I’d not encountered before.

And then there were two clues which completely stumped me: 5dn and 8dn. 5dn was “Traveller’s Rest” perhaps seen to supply cups which was STOPOVER, and 8dn The star entertainer in the line-up could tell you how to get this fruit for ANANA. Help needed on those please.

Finally the end game, and we had to find the author, FRANZ KAFKA and his place of birth, PRAGUE. Of course, we were supposed to think “No Prague, but I know that in the Czech Republic it’s PRAHA”! The trouble is that that wasn’t in the grid either. I spotted JUMBO in a diagonal, but that didn’t help, although I slotted it away for almost certain use at some point.

Listener 4187 My EntryFor me, it was about 30 minutes of floundering before I wondered if Dysart was playing a delicious trick, and I eventually found the Japanese author HARUKI MURAKAMI in the main NE-SW diagonal and near the top of the grid was his birthplace KYOTO. Bingo! And now to find his cryptically represented novels. Dance, Dance, Dance was there as 3 REELS, the 3 being the only number to be entered in the grid; KAFKA ON THE SHORE was there in rows 10 and 11. The third novel to be highlighted took me forever to find. Was it Norwegian Wood or Sputnik Sweetheart or After Dark, all of which gave ample opportunity for cryptic representation? Eventually I spotted NOR OAK in row 5 and breathed a sigh of relief. Finally, as suspected, The Elephant Vanishes required JUMBO to be erased.

So, this week, I got the better of Dysart, but he certainly tried hard. A really enjoyable and entertaining puzzle, so many thanks to him for that.

Posted in Solving Blogs | Leave a Comment »

Prize and Prize-winner by Dysart

Posted by shirleycurran on 18 May 2012

A 14×14 grid, rather a lot of clues and what looked, at first, like a carte blanche until we noticed the bars, one of those deceptively short preambles that can bode ill! There was some numpty trepidation. However, we put in putative clue numbers that fitted perfectly well and wondered. ‘The completed grid … must include one clue number only’. We are going to be hunting for titles of four works by a foreign author (as they are ‘translated titles’) so we can dismiss notions about 39 Steps and the like. (Well, Buchan was Scottish but even grumbly Listener solvers wouldn’t fuss about his title and require it to be translated into home-counties English  - would they?)

So we solve steadily and with considerable enjoyment, wondering from time to time: ‘The star entertainer in the line-up could tell you how to get this fruit (5)’ ANANA was the only fruit that fitted our ANAN? but I still don’t understand the clue. I had to go to the Internet to understand the irony of ‘Village of Wise Men became a village half-abandoned (6)’ GOT + HAM(let) since the BRB seemed to say that GOTHAM was quite the opposite of a village of wise men. ‘Memo: “A person with no regular income is out of the question!” (4)’ NOTE was the obvious answer but, again, it took me a while to grasp that such a person was rated E in BRB, thus NOT E rather subtly conveyed the solution.

Lovely clues, the rest of them! Dysart, of course, flourishing even more than the usual quantity of Listener compiler bubbly, Armagnac, wild feasting, cups and casks of punch. With glee, we spotted Franz Kafka emerging, appropriately placed in the centre of a row and, after under a couple of hours of solving, crowed with delight. We should have known better! Isn’t Dysart known for this kind of double-crossing?

A full grid, a foreign author identified, and, of course, we all know he was born in Prague and wrote ‘The Trial‘, ‘The Castle‘ and ‘Metamorphosis‘. Time for a glass of some Listener concoction or another and a break for supper.

All through dinner, that grid sat between the rice and the green Thai curried chicken and taunted us. (Yes, I have to admit, these things have invaded our Friday evening schedule and sit there malevolently.) PRAGUE simply wasn’t there even though I carefully read up and down rows, columns and diagonals … HAH! Of course, the rest is history. Didn’t I feel silly when HARUKI MURAKAMI appeared!

KYOTO of course, followed. I didn’t know that, but do know that he won the Kafka Prize, so, of course, the title now made sense. All that remained was to find four titles cryptically represented in the grid. I enjoyed After Dark but, although two friends have recommended it, felt that 1Q84, with more than 900 pages, was mildly threatening. Still, it looked promising as far as numbers went – but NO!

I am sure I am not alone in having found KAFKA on (the) SHORE first, then, of course, deleting JUMBO (which had appeared during my scanning of the diagonals) since an elephant had to vanish (The Elephant Vanishes). Dance Dance Dance seemed a likely candidate for another novel and STEPS appeared, deceptively in 28d (Feelings of offence reflected in teacher’s errors (8) PETS rev in MISS).  Of course, when the final title appeared, I still needed a number, and thus, had to transfer my vote to 3 REELS,producing the 3. What a complicated procedure we had gone to just to get that number!

There weren’t many two-word novels left in the Internet list, and, opting for Norwegian Wood meant that I had to examine all the six-letter rectangles around the letter N.  GINGKO couldn’t, by any stretch of the imagination fit the bill, but, of course, NOR OAK did.

All great fun with a lovely twist (at least for silly numpties) and a fine end-game. Thank you, Dysart!

Posted in Solving Blogs | Tagged: , , | 2 Comments »

Cuemasters by Tangram

Posted by shirleycurran on 11 May 2012

Who said that short preambles go with difficult crosswords? Tangram’s Cuemasters had a mere six lines and for the numpties, at least, it proved to be very difficult – perhaps there is some truth in that notion. We understood that there were ‘letters latent’ here, that were going to be missing from the grid entry wherever they occurred, and that these letters were going to spell out a question.

It didn’t help us that the first clues we solved left us entering real words. A quick check with Mrs Bradford told us that WROATH was Shakespeare’s ‘misfortune’ and W + RATH completed the clue, ‘Will’s misfortune with horse-drawn carriage (5)’. We entered WRATH. ‘Act of appeasement: number backed annexing bits of Czech hinterland (5)’ gave us NUM< + C(zech) H(interland). That doesn’t sound like appeasement to me but never mind. MUNCH goes into the grid.

It seemed to be too much to hope for that both the definitions and the entries produced by the wordplay were going to be real words and indeed, our hopes were dashed as wordplay led us to TREENAI, UNHARSING, WINNOWR, CATCINESS and ACTINER.

For me, this type of crossword automatically comes in at about 7 on a 1 to 10 scale of difficulty (with Mash’s Klein Bottle and Sabre’s Knights’ Moves nudging the 10 level).  The words that the numpties gleefully enter give little real help for filling the vast empty spaces on the grid.

Take 1 Across: we have found EMPUS[E] (Fliers might be damaged by such matter) (f)LU[TT]EN(t) (Essentially competent in language, allowed to come and go in Scotland) INA[U]G[U]RAL (Leaving earth, big bird soaring on maiden public exhibition) SHADBE[RR]Y (Persian king spending hot day with old Turkish governor: it bears fruit) and HICAT[E] (Tortoise I see invading cloche, eg). That means that we have the letters ELI?S?H?? for ‘Almost the best taste of India in singular tea plant (9)’ There is more than the usual grumpy numpty head-scratching.

Fortunately A MOONLIT DOOR appeared and daylight dawned (well, moonlight) as school poetry lessons were recalled. ‘”Is there anybody there?” said the Traveller, Knocking on the moonlit door; And his horse in the silence champed the grasses Of the forest’s ferny floor’. So we have a W to complete [W]EL[W]ITSCHIA at 1 across.

We had enough to suss out that we were being asked WHICH POEM A?EDAOO FEATURED A MOONLIT DOOR? Yes, we saw our error later -that AQUAMANILE/AQUAMANALE clue (Servant breaks a quality medieval jug) gave us the word play MAN in A QUALE, but we assumed that our extra letter was A when, in fact, I was needed to produce AGED 100. It was rather sneaky, though, wasn’t it, to use IOO for 100?

Still, we didn’t need that in order to see that THE ISTENERS had appeared in the tenth column, thus prompting us to put a latent letter L in the centre square (and, of course, into the CUEMASTERS title, producing CLUEMASTERS – so Roger and Shane are still alive and well despite Shark’s concern in his Continental Drift setter’s blog!)

We hadn’t quite finished. We had a Spanish province to find at 31 ac and had A?AGN. It had to be ARAGON hadn’t it with the O inserted? But that is a region of three provinces. Hmmm!

Enough grumbling. This crossword earned real admiration for the astonishing  skill of its compilation. I wonder how long it took Tangram to find those obscure words that would produce the letters latent that gave the question. What a feat! I hope he will tell us in a setter’s blog.

Posted in Solving Blogs | Tagged: , | 5 Comments »

Listener 4186: Tangram’s Cuemasters

Posted by Listen With Others on 11 May 2012

This week we had a second Listener puzzle from Tangram, with the first being just over a year ago. That featured Shelley’s Ode to the West Wind: “O, Wind, If Winter comes, can Spring be far behind?” Looking out of the window, all I can say about this spring is that it’s wet and windy, so ideal crosswording weather!

Listener 4186

Listener 4186 My EntryA straightforward Letters Latent puzzle here, with subsidiary idications leading to the entered answers. I hoped that his would be fairly straightforward, and I was off to a reasonable start with 16ac STEERABLE entered as STRABL, 19ac LIMACEL entered as LIACEL and 27ac NEEDS, NEES. 33ac Poet’s apparently removing from funeral stand as urn nigh prepared was an obvious anagram, and I guessed that a 10- or more letterd word would have at least one E, and it probably ended with –ING. I got UNH[E]ARSING fairly quickly after that.

The down clues were helped by 6dn Ruined Ionian city, having buried year sign which was an anagram of Ionian city without the Y for year. ATION was almost staring me in the face, and IN[D]ICATION was slotted into the grid.

Steady progress was made with Tangram’s puzzle, but the question posed by the latent letters was slow coming. I don’t know whether we were supposed to get befuddled over the last few letters of the across clues, but I certainly was: GEDIOOFE. Something must be wrong, but of course, it wasn’t, and soon everything was made clear:

Which poem, aged IOO featured a moonlit door?

With a little licence, the IOO becomes 100. I confess that I needed Google to remind me about the moonlit door, but Walter de la Mare’s “Is there anybody there said the traveller”, the opening line from The Listeners, immediately brought back memories of my childhood … although exactly when it was, I’m not sure. Then, as now, it sent a tingle down my spine as I read it.

All that remained was to find THE LISTENERS in the grid, and there they were, minus the L in column 10. Thus the letter making it “homologous with the title” was the L, and it could also be fitted in the title of our puzzle to give Cluemasters, perhaps a reference to Listener setters.

So thanks to Tangram for a very enjoyable puzzle and some good memories, and not too taxing after last week’s tussle with Elgin.

Posted in Solving Blogs | Leave a Comment »

Ballad by Elgin

Posted by shirleycurran on 4 May 2012

There was just a hint of Numpty consternation when we saw that name Elgin. I am told it wasn’t Elgin who once set the crossword that nobody managed to solve but that he produced one a few years ago that had a mere 32 correct solvers. Our anxiety seemed to be justified as we set to work and very, very slowly cold-solved clues with not much idea where to place our solutions

Down clues were normal and clearly the ones to work on. Looking back, I realize how generous some of these were: anagrams (always our favourite route to solving) for NARD ‘It helped in remedying right and wrong (4)’; NOTICES  ’Marks section under review (7)’; YAPSTERS ‘Try peas with special hot dogs (8)’; TRIALIST ‘What’s someone with body and soul and spirit left – is it art possibly? (8)’.

There were two hidden clues too, for ESS and SEDATE  and that ‘French’ clue with the deceptive Dickensian touch, ‘Dodger’s heading for Nancy here is potentially most dangerous (7)’ (D(odger) and ICI EST as they say locally here in the French Jura mountains for HERE and IS. Of course we didn’t immediately solve that clue, we never do see the French ones!

I read, just this week, in a comment made by Kenmac on 15 squared, that the shorter preambles lead him to expect more difficult crosswords. The six lines Elgin gave us were no exception! We had quite a lot of down clues in place and a number of across solutions (TRUSTLESSNESS, BIRTH, BORDER, BREED, EVULSED, LAMAIST, EAST, WEST and ROMEOS) but there were those worrying words ‘Across entries can go in either direction … two entries overlap … there are no clues for entries in one row… one column has been omitted’.

TRUSTLESSNESS clearly fitted in, going backwards on the bottom row (a sigh of relief) and it looked as though the extra column was going to be on the right – so I put it there. EVULSED had an evident location slotting in in reverse three rows above, so we relaxed, assuming that the lower half of the crossword was going to be reversed, the upper half heading forward. We had a glass of wine and a break for dinner.

Moving onward was hard work (was it the wine?) and, at first, our thesis seemed to work as JENNY LONGLEGS echoed TRUSTLESSNESS (producing that extra J at the start). I decided, at this point, that we were in Phi country again, and were going to have a grid that needed to be seen as a cylinder, with words circling. This was a lucky long shot!

It was about an hour later that those letters seemed to be resolving themselves into JUDGEMENT SEAT. Yes, I know we didn’t need to reinsert that line but it is in my illustration above – I like the highlighting! This, if course, helped us fit in those last few difficult little words, CAUKER, TARDY, CADEE and TEA SET which disobeyed that notion about one half reversing, but did fill lots of gaps.

There was a moment of delight when we realised that the centre line of the crossword was going to be palindromic with REDDER in the centre of SEMEMES. Now that is spectacular compiling isn’t it?

Almost there! We fitted STRAIT and STITCHES in and saw that they shared the letter S and thus fulfilled that line in the preamble ‘Note that two entries overlap!’ We had been playing with a potential HECTOR SEDUCEE on the corresponding line (symmetry-wise) in the top half of the crossword but there was a rather smelly numpty red herring there.

The Internet produces ballad evidence of Hector upbraiding Paris ‘you pretty boy, you evil seducer’ but he didn’t seduce Hector did he? We scratched our heads and wondered why those extra words BIRTH, BORDER, BREED, EAST and WEST had appeared in the solutions. Daylight dawned almost simultaneously as we recited Rudyard Kipling’s Ballad of East and West,

Oh East is East and West is West, and never the twain shall meet, Till Earth and Sky stand presently at God’s great Judgement Seat; But there is neither East nor West, Border, nor Breed, nor Birth, When two strong men stand face to face, tho’ they come from the ends of the earth!

So that was what HECTOR was doing up there. He needed to be face to face with another strong man (and even share that H with him!) HERCULES completed our grid.

Thank you Elgin. This was very challenging indeed and most enjoyable too.

Posted in Solving Blogs | Tagged: , | 1 Comment »

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.