Listen With Others

Are you sitting comfortably? Then we’ll begin

Small but Perfectly Formed by Quinapalus

Posted by shirleycurran on 2 Mar 2012

Yes, there is no denying that this little crossword was ‘Small but Perfectly Formed by Quinapalus’. It was the first one I have encountered by Quinapalus, though the name is familiar. Where do we immediately go for help when we are faced with some obscure verbal jumble or playfair code? Quinapalus, of course!

However, the preamble was anything but small. It filled almost as much space as the 27 clues and was just a mite daunting. I shelved my anxiety about ‘three dimensions … the shape of a cuboid … shown in four layers which solvers should imagine stacked in front of each other’. After all, we are becoming accustomed to the monthly BBC CiNA calendar 3D puzzles.

As usual, the clue length indicators were helpful, since we could at once see how many letters were coming out of the ‘Width’ clues. I slotted in PORTIERE as PORTIR and wondered whether this  puzzle could continue to be so gentle. Indeed, it was! The solutions just fell into place and very soon we had SHAPE written alongside our width clues.

I jumped to the wrong conclusion and decided that we were hearing Shakespeare’s Mercutio, telling us that Queen Mab ‘is the fairies’ midwife – she comes in shape etc.’ but soon realized that we were in a far more sombre tragedy when the rest of the excerpt appeared and we heard King Lear telling us ‘My dimensions are as well compact/ My mind as generous and my shape as true …’

This device of clues in three dimensions was magic and, with the help of Crossword Compiler’s ‘find word’ device, we soon had an almost full grid.

No numpty red herrings? Of course we had! The very last clue was one of the first we solved and although we couldn’t justify the E at the end, we slotted in ASSERTIVE (When very laid back one’s against claiming one’s rights) AS + TRES (rev) + I + V (against). You can imagine what a mess that made of the north-east corner of our grid. Of course, ASSERTION was required.

We had three blanks in our grid when all our words were neatly in place but, of course, the endgame filled those for us. I had been dreading the moment when I would have to confront those conflicting concepts – a cuboid, three dimensions, four stacked layers. However, the quotation appeared after just a few moments’ head scratching, just as Phi is claiming the endgame should, in his essay in the editorial section of the February Crossword Magazine. (Not a bad rule of thumb is it? One should certainly not have to spend more than twice as much time on the pay-off as in solving the clues!)

I though this was a delightful and very ingenious compilation. Easy – but I am not complaining, especially when we are expecting a nightmare numerical puzzle next week. A Friday evening Listen With Others blog is a rare event for me but a thoroughly enjoyable one. Thanks to Quinapalus!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: