Listen With Others

Are you sitting comfortably? Then we’ll begin

Listener 4233: Elementary by Wan (or Don’t Let Him Near the Lab!)

Posted by Dave Hennings on 5 Apr 2013

This was Wan’s first Listener, although he has had an EV and a few Magpie outings. Here we had an old favourite, the periodic table, but with a neat twist: every clue had to have the two-letter symbol of one element replaced by that of another before it could be solved.

Listener 4233 Chemical SymbolsLike the ‘setter’, chemistry isn’t my strongest suit, so my first job was to print out a list of elements and their symbols, preferably in alphabetical order. A visit to a couple of websites and a paste into Word got this onto a single page. I wondered whether there might be situations where the wrong symbol needed to be removed from one word, with the correct symbol needing to be added to another. I thought that unlikely, but I’d try to keep an eye open for one or two such instances. (It turned out that there were none.)

I gazed blankly at the first half-dozen or so across clues with nothing jumping out at me. Even 14ac Prince ate a protected animal … (5) passed me by until about half an hour later; it was, of course, PANDA (ate became and). 19ac Feet ache or hurt (6) looked like CHOREA or CHOREE, but again HORACE would take some time to make himself known (feet was poet). My first success was 23, where Tail Coil left on scoundrel (4) gave CURL.

Listener 4233And so I was off. It was great fun teasing out the substitutions that were required. Sometimes they were in the definition, as in 23, sometimes in the wordplay like 7 Last of the Muses could be contributing to passion in snatches (5) with its ‘simple’, ‘hidden’ NINTH!

All the surface readings were excellent; I particularly liked the sick bag for the dodgy picnic! However, my favourite clues had to be these:

2dn AVID Greedy helper eats two more than these
these becoming three was a delight
10dn IRISH COFFEE Officer initially exceeds his roaming coverage
we’ve all had problems with mobile phone coverage, not necessarily so with beverages
16ac BHUTAN … tabu outside last of Hutu land whence it came, perhaps
reference to the preceding answer, PANDA, with the last letter of Hutu becoming all but, ie most
17dn UPTOWN In court, won’t betray where Yanks might live
It took me ages to suss astray for betray!
18ac SPEED TRAP Monitored section of road in drug scare
Monitored needed to be read as an adjective rather than past tense (I think Chambers has speed trap as two words)

I made a complete list of which symbol moved from which clue and where it went. The clue that evaded me until the very end was 28ac. Well, obviously it was TOUCHWOOD, but I just couldn’t resolve the clue: Perform art with supposedly supernatural power from tinder. I could see that the supposedly supernatural power was OD. After all, Chambers gives that as ‘Reichenbach’s arbitrary name for a force he supposed to manifest itself in light, magnetism, chemical action, hypnotism, etc’. OK, so ‘supernatural’ may not apply (although hypnotism has always struck me as a bit weird), but ‘supposedly and ‘power’ fitted perfectly. TOUCH can be to play a musical instrument, but the WO eluded me. Of course, it was a ‘simple’ double definition, with art becoming act, and needed me to pronounce it as touch’wood in one sense and touch’ wood’, with a pause, in the other.

Listener 4233 My EntryWith the grid complete, all I had to do was highlight ‘two rows that conceal the full name of someone whose creation might have proved helpful’. Note the wording here. If his name was concealed in the rows, why were we required to highlight the complete row? Obviously all the letters were relevant, and the two rows provided an anagram of his full name. (The advantage of writing a blog is that you can make it sound as though you came to a conclusion ahead of time, rather than in hindsight. Truth be known, I thought it might be someone called VINCE or HORACE!)

And so the letters of Dmitri Ivanovich Mendeleev could be found in rows 2 and 11, and a thoroughly enjoyable puzzle came to an end.

I don’t know how detailed the Listener web site will be for the solution to this puzzle, so here’s a full list of substitutions if you need it.

Clue word Symbol from becomes from giving
1ac PENAL Al 22 Ce 20 PENCE
2dn THESE Es 15 Re 22 THREE
3dn PAIR Ir 34 In 31 PAIN
4dn NEED Ne 26 Br 33 BRED
5dn BATHE Ba 32 Li 34 LITHE
6dn MOCKS Mo 16 La 16 LACKS
8dn SPOKE Po 19 Ta 23 STAKE
9dn GAZE Ga 13 Si 25 SIZE
11ac SMEAR Sm 33 Cl 35 CLEAR
12ac CUTS Cu 21 Ra 30 RATS
13ac THINS Th 7 Ga 9 GAINS
14ac ATE Te 30 Nd 15 AND
15dn TREND Nd 14 Es 2 TREES
16ac LAST La 6 Mo 6 MOST
17dn BETRAY Be 10 As 24 ASTRAY
18ac SCARE Sc 35 Sn 7 SNARE
19ac FEET Fe 20 Po 8 POET
20dn LICE Ce 1 Fe 19 LIFE
21dn AGE Ag 31 Cu 12 CUE
22ac TREK Re 2 Al 1 TALK
23ac TAIL Ta 8 Co 10 COIL
24dn MASK As 17 Ar 28 MARK
25ac SICK Si 9 Ni 32 NICK
26dn BOAT At 36 Ne 4 BONE
27dn PUBS Pu 29 Ca 29 CABS
28ac ART Ar 24 Ac 36 ACT
29ac CAT Ca 27 Pu 27 PUT
30dn RAN Ra 12 Te 14 TEN
31dn PINE In 3 Ag 21 PAGE
34ac LION Li 5 Ir 3 IRON
35ac CLAN Cl 11 Sc 18 SCAN
36ac PLACE Ac 28 At 26 PLATE


One Response to “Listener 4233: Elementary by Wan (or Don’t Let Him Near the Lab!)”

  1. Wan said

    Thanks for your very kind blog. It has been a nervy time waiting to see if solvers enjoyed it so I am very pleased to hear that you did. There are things that I could have done better of that I am sure but I have much to learn.

    Best wishes


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: