Listen With Others

Are you sitting comfortably? Then we’ll begin

Listener 4279: Hellside by eXternal

Posted by Dave Hennings on 21 February 2014

The first debut setter of 2014 with a puzzle from eXternal, although he/she has had a couple of Inquisitors in the last year or so. This week, we had a version of a song to find, and I wondered how similar it might be to John Lennon’s Imagine in the same weekend’s EV puzzle, Dreams. Here we had definitions missing from six down clues, but provided by extra letters in across clues, thematically presented.

Listener 42791ac Beast tucked into American spices and cinnamon (6) looked like it should read East tucked into American spices, but CASSIA meant that it was Beast tucked into American spies, ie ASS in CIA. Next came 5ac, where the extra letter was almost certainly the D in ‘powder’, and we had G + RAP + P + A giving GRAPPA (a quite disgusting drink from what I remember when I tried it back in the 70’s).

With the two clues across the top of the grid, I tried a few downs. 1 CLEF, 3 SEWER, 4 ARGUES, 6 APERIES and finally 7 Empty pool linked to shivering fit (6) PLAGUE provided the first thematic clue without a definition. It sounded like we might have quite a gruesome theme!

Down the left-hand side, and I got 11ac Notice wit[c]h scold flatterer (6) EARWIG, although I wasn’t too sure that ‘ear’ = ‘notice’, but Mrs B gives both under attention. A flurry of clues followed, including 14ac FRIER, 15ac USER and 30ac DUST. HARVESTER, undefined at 9dn meant the left side was nearly finished, but gave no clue as to what it had in common with PLAGUE … or even SUBDUE sitting mysteriously at 17dn.

As I moved on to the right-hand side of the grid, I was also becoming a tad concerned about the extra letters being dropped from the across clues. My inability to make anything logical from them reminded me of Pointer’s Conflict a few weeks before. The right side was finished reasonably quickly, with my favourite clue at 12dn Cane rampant man in black rubber (6), which had nothing to do with S&M but the referee in football (REF< + ULE).

And so, the six words without definition were shown to be, in clue order, PLAGUE – HARVESTER – SUBDUE – PRISON – SOAR – LASH. The extra letters in the across clues spelt out .


Actually, looking at it there in nice neat Tahoma font rather than my scrawly pencilling alongside the clues, it almost seems obvious, although perhaps that’s just hindsight talking. Harvester made me think of reaper, perhaps the Grim Reaper, which could tie in with PLAGUE and the Hellish title. Needless to say, I was stumped so I looked up Seven in Brewer’s to see if that gave any clue… which it didn’t.

Listener 4279 My EntryI decided to come back to it the following day. 24 hours later and I looked up subdue in Chambers Crossword Dictionary (Mrs B had gone walkabout). Staring me in the face was 03 cow. I didn’t need to look at the extra letters to realise that we were singing about the old woman who swallowed more than a healthy person should, namely:

a FLY (soar) in a SPIDER (harvester) in a BIRD (prison) in a CAT (lash) in a DOG (plague) in a COW (subdue)

All that was left was for her to swallow a horse. Easy? Well, not quite. How could “cryptically representing the main protagonist and the final member of the set with a comment on their fate” be represented in nine characters? All I can say is that after about a quarter of an hour, NAG and HAG came to mind, and the two Gs enabled me to see GG in row 4, surrounded by WIFE. Above was RIP — she’s dead, of course. The title is the answer to the cryptic clue “Perhaps she’ll die”.

Great fun. Thanks, eXternal.

Of course, the song is nothing like Lennon’s Imagine!

4 Responses to “Listener 4279: Hellside by eXternal”

  1. Jockie said

    That’s my 100% record shot, rather earlier in the year than I would have liked. 14A was the problem – I had FRIED, which seemed to be defined by “in pa(i)n”. FR is clearly “religious man” but why is “cried out” IER? But even having fallen at this hurdle it was a splendid puzzle – thanks eXternal.

  2. Sorry to hear of your early exit, Jockie – it’s always annoying when something simple trips us up. I must admit that I was a bit perplexed by “in pa[i]n” at first. I think the “in” is just a linkword (albeit at the beginning of the clue!) with the meaning “consisting of” (in Chambers). (I can’t say that I’m an expert on these linkwords, nor that I necessarily like them all.) “Cried out” just means it’s a homophone of FRIAR.

  3. Jaguar said

    I felt the highlighting was a bit too cryptic, but otherwise a clever solve and debut for a new setter. Here’s hoping for more from eXternal in future.

  4. shirleycurran said

    Grappa is quite tasty, Dave, when you get it as an Italian speciality, all hot and spiced up, with coffee, in a wooden bowl that has six spouts. It is passed round until everyone is fairly happy (to put it mildly!) It’s the sort of thing that might go down a bomb in the Listener Setters’ tipsy club.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: