Listen With Others

Are you sitting comfortably? Then we'll begin

Posts Tagged ‘The Cask of Amontillado’

Get Me Out of Here! by Nemo

Posted by shirleycurran on 19 May 2017

I have to admit that when I saw Nemo’s grid and read his preamble that told us that 38 answers were to follow ‘a path of contiguous, not barred-off cells from its number to one of the dots, without revisiting any cell along its path’ my initial reaction was ‘Get Me Out of Here!’ Of course, we were instantly thinking of clown fish and the children’s favourite Nemo. Was this a new setter or an old hand masquerading under a new pseudonym? The quality of the clue-writing certainly suggested the second. Surely some old hand wasn’t going to have a little clown fish tipped down a toilet and making its way to the sea along windy paths. Nothing to do but to get down to solving.

Well, there was, of course, that important check of whether Nemo will be invited into the Listener Setters’ Oenophile Outfit and he left us with little doubt. C4 ‘Ingredient of pick-me up is mountain plant (3)’ was a starter, producing only one possible word, MEU, which the Big Red Book confirmed to be a plant. ‘Drunken curate spilling a bottle of Dom? (5)’ gave us CURATE less A* and we got our CRUET which the BRB told us was ‘a vessel for wine or water for religious ceremonies’. ‘Reasons for leaving fizz there in Italy (4)’ brought in that fizzy white stuff that seems to be so popular in the UK, PROSECCO, with the PROS or ‘reasons for’ leaving just the ECCO. (What a superb clue!) Nemo might have left the fizzy in Italy but he continued with ‘Drink at Ed’s pub a series of rounds (5)’ – another lovely surface reading that gave us CHA+IN. There was more – ‘Knock back energy drink after I am shut up (5)’ E RUM after IM giving IMMURE, and then ‘Dad returned after imbibing one for Wally? (8)’. That one kept us head-scratching for a while at the end of our solve before yielding PA + LATER< around I to give PARIETAL which means ‘of a wall’. More clever cluing! Well, cheers, Nemo, little doubt about your place at the bar at the next setters’ dinner!

Of course, Nemo hadn’t finished with his alcoholic theme but THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO and its gory details were a long way ahead of us at this stage as we attempted to initially complete the rows then take those winding paths through them. I have inserted that neat little innocuous diagram at the head of my blog but how little it represents the reality of Tipp-ex and highlighters that kept us going up to dinner, via the first G & T and way beyond until almost midnight. No, this was not easy. The problem was that we needed to have all the rows in place to render the winding paths easier to establish and several of those affected the ones around them.

All went  fairly well until we reached the northwest corner. We had already used the R with a dot, for LEAGUER but we needed it if COAL-PORTER was to finish at an R, we couldn’t take the singer miner (how I liked that play on Cole Porter’s name!) to the top of the grid, since PLATEAU already went up there. I have read on the Answerbank, this morning, that other solvers immediately spotted the author and theme. How much easier it would have been if we had done that – but it was not to be.

We had finally moved OUTRED and LEAGUER and had a full grid (though had to back solve to find ROQUELAURE which was fully checked) with every solution in place before we found EDGAR ALLAN POE. Of course with the two Latin phrases staring us in the face, and …TILLADO appearing heading down to cell 6, the endgame was a gift, and I felt that we had earned one after that hard work. Of course I reread the evil

Jugged HSREA

little story and found a number of familiar words in there: ROQUELAURE, CRYPT, MOTLEY, and CHAIN to name a few, and, of course, a number of clues were thematic, ‘Primarily nitre accumulates to a great extent around inner chamber’, ‘…I am shut up’ and those words IMMURE and PARIETAL. In addition to the superb cluing, this puzzle was delightfully thematic with even a grid like the wall the insane MONTRESOR constructs so laboriously at the end of the story. Welcome to Nemo with this masterful debut and many thanks.

Ah yes, the HARES. they were there, of course, but in a rather confused bunch of HSREA up there at the top left hand corner of Montresor’s wall. They must have been (like me) desperately attempting to follow winding paths, afraid to find themselves jugged in a cask of amontillado.

Advertisements

Posted in Solving Blogs | Tagged: , , | Leave a Comment »

Get Me Out Of Here! by Nemo

Posted by Encota on 19 May 2017

First of all, thanks to Nemo for a tough, challenging puzzle!

So it wasn’t a reference to the TV feast that is “I Have Delusions of Being a Celebrity, GMOOH”, after all.  As an aside, I trust all in Listener land have passed the “Which one is Ant & which one is Dec?” test?  The best solution that I have been offered is:

  • They always stand in alphabetical order when viewed on your screen.

L4448solution

Meanwhile, back to the puzzle.  The PDM when spotting the theme was excellent, I thought.  Luckily the bottom right corner meant that there were few options for how it ended, so finding THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO was relatively straightforward.  I understand that some describe this as ‘the perfect short story’ and it is one that I haven’t yet read, so I will be doing so in the very near future (thanks again Listener for an educational prompt!).

So EDGAR ALLAN POE, MONTRESOR and FORTUNATO soon went in to fit with Row answers already in place and it took only a little more investigation to find the phrase (NEMO) ME IMPUNE LACESSIT from the story.

My poorly remembered Latin meant I struggled for a little with the lower phrase but when the word REQUIESCAT (rather than QUIESCAT that I’d been hunting for – d’oh!) popped to mind, then a small amount of research found the whole phrase and the thematic part was complete.  The first PDF of the short story that I found had ‘helpfully’ translated the Latin phrases out of it, which slowed me down a wee while!

As far as solving time was concerned I was at that stage, however, only about a third through this puzzle!  The path-based clues were a real challenge and I took half a day’s rest before coming back to sort out the last four or five.  Last few for me were:

  • 33.    Dad returned after imbibing one for Wally? (8)
    PARIETAL as PA + I in LATER<
  • 21.  Opponent of Huguenot siege, once (7)
    LEAGUER, dd
  • 22.  Drink at Ed’s pub a series of rounds (5)
    CHAIN, CHA IN, with the IN (clued as Ed’s pub) catching me out for ages,
    I won’t forget that one!
  • 13.  Rattly breath of spirit with short time to go (4)
    RALE, which initially I thought was a cryptic clue, until after the
    event I spotted (mo)RALE
  • 2.    Cooler?  This croaker may end up there (4)
    ICER, can’t really see why it’s this even though several of the words
    are relevant.  Luckily the checked letters sorted this one for me.  Is it just a
    morgue / chiller angle?  All hints welcomed

And prior to that, C3 Leaves navy of old coastal city (4), i.e.
TEAN had taken me ages, though it’s obvious in retrospect, like many good clues.  I spent far too long trying to apply the shoe-horn, assuming the answer (for some reason known only to myself) to be GOAN.

I did feel the need to double-check that each dot had been used once and once only, as my draft grid had got a bit ‘busy’ by the time I had indicated to myself which path was which.  I eventually opted for the diagram below, just to convince myself…

L4448paths

At least twice I ended up re-printing out the grid and trying to double-check which end dots I had – and hadn’t – already used, to try and get a bit more inspiration for the last few Answers above.

My favourite three clues all involved definitions that were not all they at first seemed:

   Dad returned after imbibing one for Wally? (8)

PARIETAL, with the definition of ‘Wally?’ for ‘wall-like’ raising a smile, and

   Wanton desire to receive a perk, possibly (5)

LEACH, with ‘perk’ being short for percolate a superb piece of deception, I felt!

And finally

   Break clean from a faction?

ROMAN A CLEF, with the deceptive definition of ‘faction’ for ‘fact-based fiction’ rather than its surface reading again making me grin!

With all the paths to chase down, this was one of the harder Listeners of the year so far.  The last five ‘meandering’ clues went in during the following day, which has been something of a rarity in 2017.

Cheers

Tim / Encota

Posted in Solving Blogs | Tagged: , , , | Leave a Comment »